Joe Davis on The Generous Leader: Why Clear Feedback and Better Questions Matter More in the Age of AI

You are currently viewing Joe Davis on The Generous Leader: Why Clear Feedback and Better Questions Matter More in the Age of AI

A conversation with Joe Davis, former head of BCG North America and author of The Generous Leader

Executive Summary

AI is making the human side of leadership more important. Joe Davis spent 37 years at Boston Consulting Group, led BCG North America and co-founded BCG Digital Ventures. In The Generous Leader: 7 Ways to Give of Yourself for Everyone’s Gain, he distils those decades into a simple proposition: a leader’s job is to help others grow, thrive and develop.

Joined by Mark Blackwell on Arkaro Insights, Joe explains why the command and control model of the white shirt and blue suit has run its course. Work and life have blurred, anxiety is rising and the next boss to appear on stage may be a hologram. People want a leader they can trust and talk to. Generosity, in Joe’s sense, has little to do with money or warmth. It can mean telling someone plainly that they are in the wrong role.

The conversation ranges from mushy feedback and the courage to say “I don’t know” to why most AI projects stall on the human side, and why the most junior person in the room should get the first question.

Core Insights

  • Clear feedback is a gift. Mushy feedback confuses people and keeps them stuck. Direct, specific feedback frees them to act.
  • The best leaders ask questions. Every executive Joe interviewed shared one trait: they ask questions, ask questions, ask questions.
  • “I don’t know” unlocks teams. A leader who admits uncertainty gives everyone else permission to do the same, and the work moves again.
  • AI projects fail on the human side. The technology usually works. The processes, roles and habits around it do not change unless leaders make them.
  • Engage the sceptics and uncover the nos. The person everyone finds a pain in the neck often knows the small thing that will sink the project.
  • Say it three times. A message lands only when people have heard it, absorbed it and connected it, which rarely happens the first time.
  • Small acts have big impact. A two-line email of thanks can matter more to someone than a pay rise.

The End of the White Shirt and Blue Suit

Joe dates the change to the BlackBerry. Once work could ping you at a Saturday barbecue, the boundary between work and life began to dissolve. The mobile phone accelerated it and COVID crushed what was left. Add rising anxiety, particularly among younger people, and employees now bring their whole human selves to work whether leaders invite them or not.

That changes what people need from the person in charge. Joe is careful to credit Jack Welch as an incredible leader who cared deeply, but who behaved in a way that would not land today. Nor would the old IBM model in which you were “fine, but you’re just a cog in the wheel.”

AI pushes this further. Joe recalls a BCG worldwide officer meeting at which the CEO, sitting in Europe, appeared on stage in North America as a hologram.

“I thought, wait a minute, now I’ve got him up there, but he ain’t human… this desire to have a human leader is only gonna accelerate when there can be pretend leaders.”

The day may come when AI manages people. When it does, Joe argues, people will ask where the boss is that they can trust, touch and talk to.

Generosity Is Not Unicorns and Fluffy Clouds

Joe’s definition of generous leadership is demanding. It has nothing to do with pay rises. The role of a leader is to help others grow, thrive and develop, ideally without expecting direct personal benefit, because people can tell when the help is really for you.

That sometimes means letting someone go. Joe tells the story of a European partner, a rock star at home, who struggled after transferring to America. BCG’s rule was that a partner who fell short three years in a row was out. Joe thought about what the man must be going through at night, then sat him down.

“You have three choices. You go home, you quit or I fire you. You pick. That’s all I said. I didn’t mush it up.”

The partner thanked him, went home and became a rock star again. A younger colleague asked how Joe could be so blunt. His answer was that he had taken the time to understand where the man’s head was, and then freed him.

Mark connected this to Hilary Scarlett’s SPACES model, discussed in an earlier episode. Our brains are wired to seek certainty, so much so that people who know bad news about their future can be less stressed than those left guessing. Mushy feedback denies people that certainty. Joe’s second story makes the point: a BCG consultant sat through ten minutes of vague explanation before turning to Joe and asking, “Am I being fired?” When Joe said yes, the man said thank you.

The lesson came to Joe early. As a 24-year-old Procter & Gamble sales manager, he rode with his older sales reps every two weeks and never told them anything. When he finally unloaded a year’s worth of observations in an annual review, his rep stopped him a minute in: why had he never said any of this before? The rep wanted the feedback. Joe had simply been afraid to give it, and he sees the same fear in leaders of 35, 45 and 50.

“There’s nothing worse than, hey, that was a great presentation, but you ought to really work on your delivery… What do you mean? Talk slower, talk faster? I don’t know what to do with that.”

.

Ask Questions, Ask Questions, Ask Questions

Listening depends on a degree of vulnerability, the humility to accept, and ideally to show, that you do not have all the answers. Joe describes a colleague who was so afraid of admitting ignorance that he would leave the room whenever he sensed his team was about to ask him something he could not answer. The team stayed stuck and time was lost.

One day he stayed and said, “I don’t know.” The room burst open. Nobody else knew either, and once that was out in the open the brainstorming could finally start.

“So ‘I don’t know’ is three simple words that are very powerful.”

Joe adds a sensible caveat: the maths teacher cannot claim not to know what two plus two is. Expertise still matters. The point is to stop pretending it covers everything.

Engage the Sceptics and Uncover the Nos

Mark raised a point from Professor Joseph Fuller of Harvard Business School: businesses often hand AI projects to a dream team of thirty- to forty-year-old executives. Fuller’s advice is to mix in the veteran who knows where the skeletons are buried with younger people who are AI literate and close to the bottlenecks on the shop floor.

Joe agrees and offers a cautionary tale from BCG’s work on the Starbucks app. The technology worked. Nothing changed, because the marketing team still worked as it always had, and it took another year of redesigning processes and ways of working before the app delivered. Joe believes the same human gap explains why, on his reading of BCG analysis, only around 10 to 15% of AI projects have delivered value so far.

His remedy is to look beyond your cronies and sycophants.

“Go engage the skeptics and uncover the nos… Everyone thinks that person’s a pain in the neck, but they actually know something that you want to know. And it could be teeny, but if you don’t figure out the teeny, the whole thing doesn’t work.”

In large change efforts, one of Joe’s BCG partners would seek out the 30 troublemakers and the 10 or 20 people buried in the organisation who carry its culture. They need not join the project team. They can sit on the steering committee. Mark’s experience is that these no-ologists often become the strongest champions once someone has listened to the flaw they spotted. Joe sees a human reason for that: ask someone a question, act on the answer, and you may win a follower for life.

The Most Junior Person Gets the First Question

Joe almost always directs his first question in a meeting to the most junior person present, or seeks out the analyst who did the work rather than the vice president presenting it three layers up. Heads turn, and the signal is clear: we are all in this room together. As Mark observes, if the first voice is a senior one, everything that follows bends towards it and insight is lost.

There is a caveat. A junior finance analyst once froze when Joe questioned her in a meeting. His chief of staff explained that, to her, the head of North America was simply scary. Joe started meeting her one to one, letting her explain her work at her own pace, until she was comfortable in the room. He took the extra step because he did not want talent hidden behind fear.

An Honest Team for the Big Speech

Preparing for his first worldwide officer meeting as head of North America, addressing around 700 partners, Joe gathered an unusual group to test his talk: his coach, chief of staff, one senior partner, his assistant, the meeting organiser and his wife, “because she’d call bullshit immediately.” His coach later called the group stunning. The value lay in honesty. People who know you well will tell you when a line will make you sound like a jerk.

Make It Land: Test the Message and Say It Three Times

Leaders often believe they have communicated when they have only spoken. Joe shares two techniques. The first comes from Joaquin Duato, CEO of Johnson & Johnson. Before a major town hall to a workforce of around 100,000, Duato practises his speech with five or ten people from all levels and asks what they heard. If they heard “direct” when he meant “clear”, he writes it down. Then he asks what they would tell their family at dinner that evening. If that is not his message, he rewrites the speech.

“It was my problem, not their problem. They listened. It wasn’t clear.”

The second is the rule of three, which Joe learned from his BCG mentor. The first time you make a point, people hear part of it while working out what the game is. The second time, they are thinking about last night or today’s shopping. By the third time, they finally put two and two together. Joe and his mentor would deliberately reinforce each other’s points in client meetings for exactly this reason. A colleague later told him about a pair of Russian ice skaters who repeated the same move three times, because a commentator explained that the judges only truly register it on the third.

 

Honest Upwards, Pilots on the Ground

Mark closed with a dilemma many leaders face. Boards and investors want clarity, certainty and a return on large AI investments. Inside the organisation, AI is still experimental territory where some things will work and others will not.

Joe’s advice has two parts. Upwards, be honest: say what you are investing in, what you hope to achieve and how you plan to get there, admit you are not certain and keep the board informed. Do not promise a 10% decline in some cost within six months, because a smart board will write it down.

On the ground, apply the lesson BCG has learned over forty years of technology change: pilot, test, adjust, and repeat. Pick something with real value, prove it works, then build on it. Tell your staff the same thing, because a workforce promised miracles believes them even less than a board does.

Joe also points to the people question many leaders skip. On his recollection of a Deloitte study, around half of employees believe leaders are introducing AI with no thought for what it means for them. What will change in my work? Which processes will be different? When Joe asked BCG’s technology practice about AI and people while writing the book some four or five years ago, the answer was that they had not started thinking about it yet. That has since changed, but the question remains the one leaders most need to answer.

What to Do on Monday Morning

Asked for one piece of advice leaders could act on immediately, Joe offered two.

  1. Ask questions, ask questions, ask questions. It costs nothing, you can start tomorrow, and it changes how people experience your leadership.
  2. Take a small act that matters to the other person. A happy birthday message. An email when someone has done a hell of a job, which they can print or keep on their phone.

Joe tells of a coach whose daughter received a short email of praise from her boss. The family spent the whole dinner dissecting it with pride. A 10% raise, she said, would have earned a “good for you, honey” and nothing more.

The bigger example came from Scott Kirby, CEO of United Airlines. After George Floyd was murdered, Kirby called every Black captain at the airline simply to check in, without offering answers. Later, one of those captains met Kirby’s wife on a flight and told her that, because of it, she would follow him anywhere. The calls probably lasted two minutes each.

“Ask questions, take a small act, have a big impact.”

What This Means for Agriculture, Food and Chemicals

Many leaders in our sectors rose through technical expertise, whether in agronomy, formulation, process engineering or supply chain. That makes the pull to have every answer especially strong, and AI is exactly the kind of challenge where nobody does. Joe’s habits translate directly: open the AI steering meeting with a question to the planner or plant operator closest to the work, give the veteran sceptic a seat at the table, and be honest with the board about what is a pilot and what is proven.

This is the territory of the Arkaro Approach. In Understand and Co-create, the most valuable insight usually sits with the people furthest from the boardroom. In Enable and Sustain, change sticks when people feel heard and know clearly where they stand, which is precisely what generous leadership provides.

Listen to the Full Conversation

Joe and Mark cover clear feedback, generous listening, the courage to say “I don’t know”, engaging the sceptics on AI projects, the rule of three and the small acts that have a big impact.

About Joe Davis

Joe Davis spent 37 years at Boston Consulting Group, where he served as head of BCG North America, co-founded BCG Digital Ventures and founded the firm’s Centre for Inclusion and Equity. He began his career as a sales representative and sales manager at Procter & Gamble. His book, The Generous Leader: 7 Ways to Give of Yourself for Everyone’s Gain, draws on interviews with senior executives and nearly four decades of leading people, and is available on Amazon and from all good bookshops.

Related Reading from the Arkaro Insights Archive

On feedback, listening and leading without all the answers

On AI as a human challenge

On change done with people